In 2021, Google unveiled a distinctive feature for its Pixel smartphones: the “camera bar.” This prominent design element stretched across the back of the phone, ostensibly to accommodate the camera lenses, but it served a dual purpose, functioning as both style and marketing. While other devices utilize more compact designs, the camera bar created a signature look that Google proudly identifies as a “hallmark feature” of its lineup.

However, not everyone is enamored with this design choice. Many users find it to be an unwelcome feature.

Since the Pixel 6, the camera bar has become a ubiquitous part of each new Pixel iteration, much to the annoyance of those who carry the phones regularly. It collects dust, creates awkward bulges in phone cases, and complicates one-handed use or landscape mode. Thankfully, Google has finally offered an alternative for those averse to this design. Earlier this year, the introduction of the Pixel 9a marked the first instance where a Pixel phone has been released without the camera bar since the original model, making it an appealing choice.

How Does the Pixel 9a Stack Up Against the Pixel 9?

Google Pixel 9a available in various colors
Credit: Michelle Ehrhardt

Every spring, Google typically releases an “a” version of its latest Pixels, featuring reduced specifications at a budget-friendly price point. Previous models have generally been well-received, with their minimal compromises offering a near-identical experience to their flagship counterparts. However, the Pixel 9a stands out as a worthy contender against the more premium Pixel 9.

Sporting the same Google Tensor G4 processor, a 6.3-inch display with a 120Hz refresh rate, and even a slightly lighter weight paired with a larger battery, the Pixel 9a almost matches the Pixel 9. It does have less memory and features a camera with fewer megapixels, but for those who primarily use their phones for web apps, the Pixel 9a delivers comparable performance, inclusive of exclusive Pixel software like Audio Eraser. In fact, if you held a Pixel 9a and a Pixel 9 side by side, the differences would probably go unnoticed for a significant period.

Why the Disdain for the Camera Bar?

Rear view of the Google Pixel 9
Credit: Michelle Ehrhardt

The discontent surrounding the Pixel camera bar stems from several issues, which some may deem trivial depending on personal preferences. The design makes it slightly cumbersome to fit into tight pockets or small bags, and it can be less comfortable to hold horizontally, which may be problematic for gamers. Additionally, the camera bar attracts dust, and its thickness prevents the phone from lying completely flat on surfaces.

However, the primary complaint is aesthetic: the camera bar is widely regarded as unattractive. Though taste is subjective, this sentiment has been echoed frequently enough that Google felt the need to defend the design. The unwanted bulk can be significant, as seen in the base Pixel 9, where the protrusion is about a third of the device’s thickness. This unsightly feature makes it clear why some users would prefer an alternative design.

How Does the Camera on the Pixel 9a Perform?

The Pixel 9a’s decision to eliminate the camera bar in favor of a more understated camera module has been a positive change for many. The new configuration allows for a near-flush fit in one corner, which enhances the overall ergonomics of the phone, making it easier to handle and enabling it to lay flat on surfaces.

While the Pixel 9 boasts a 50 MP wide lens and a 48 MP ultra-wide lens, the Pixel 9a features a 48 MP wide lens and a 13 MP ultra-wide lens. However, the argument can be made that you’re purchasing a smartphone, not a dedicated camera. If top-tier photography isn’t a principal concern, the Pixel 9a presents a more manageable and cost-effective alternative. Although the differences between photo quality exist, the Pixel 9a remains a solid option for casual photographers.

Here are some example shots taken with the Pixel 9a under various conditions:

Sample photos captured by the Pixel 9a
Credit: Michelle Ehrhardt

For comparison, here are photos taken with the standard Pixel 9:

Sample photos captured by the Pixel 9
Credit: Michelle Ehrhardt

Is the Pixel 10 Launching Soon?

Even if the Pixel 9a appeals to users, there’s a significant upcoming announcement—the Pixel 10 is scheduled for release later this month. However, Google has confirmed that this new device will still feature a camera bar—likely a prominent one at that.

Optimism for a shift in design was present with the Pixel 9a, but it seems unlikely that the trend will shift with the Pixel 10. For those who are still not fond of the camera bar, the Pixel 9a will remain a relevant choice well into the future, especially since a Pixel 10a release may not occur until next year, adhering to historical patterns.

The Pixel 9a may also hold appeal for those who prefer alternative brands, especially as recent leaks indicate that the iPhone 17 Pro and Pro Max may introduce a similar elongated camera bump, though the accuracy of these rumors remains in question.