Prior to diving into the world of e-ink notebooks, the prospect of using a stylus on a digital medium was not something I had considered deeply. Naturally, there would be a certain adjustment required; it was clear the experience would likely be inferior to writing on traditional paper. The allure of these devices lies in their myriad advantages—such as enhanced organization, cloud integration, and the ability to convert handwritten notes into text. The unique sensation of writing on such a device was just an inevitable compromise.

However, upon testing the Supernote Manta and the reMarkable Paper Pro, both designed to elevate the notebook experience without sacrificing the joy of writing, my perspective shifted. After thoroughly examining both options, I can confidently state that they offer a gratifying writing experience. Despite their shared goal, they adopt quite different methodologies to achieve it.

For those seeking to transition from traditional pen and paper to a digital format while still cherishing the sensation of writing, either device is likely to meet your expectations. Detailed reviews of each can provide further insights into their unique features and performances. The real question is, which one should you select? Here are five key aspects to consider before making your decision.